Virtues Matter – Hope

“The power of God is capable of finding hope where hope no longer exists, and a way where the way is impossible.” (St. Gregory of Nyssa)

In imagery and description the virtue of hope is a play between tensions. Hope moves one into the future – “Hope is the theological virtue by which we desire the kingdom of heaven and eternal life as our happiness, placing out trust in Christ’s promises and relying not on our own strength, but on the help of the grace of the Holy Spirit.” (CCC #1817) – yet hope is often symbolized as an anchor – “Hope is the ‘sure and steadfast anchor of the soul … that enters … where Jesus has gone as a forerunner on our behalf.’” (CCC #1820) This play of tensions reveals the always dynamic quality of true hope and also why hope always eludes a static definition. It seems that it is the very nature of hope to remain unbounded.

This unbounded nature to hope is due, I believe, to the fact that God himself has placed a yearning and “not yet” quality in the heart of every man and woman. “The virtue of hope responds to the aspiration to happiness which God has placed in the heart of every man; it takes up the hopes that inspire men’s activities and purifies them so as to order them to the Kingdom of heaven…” And also that God has answered this yearning in Christ and in the continual unfolding of the Kingdom, “Christian hope unfolds from the beginning of Jesus’ preaching in the proclamation of the beatitudes. The beatitudes raise our hope toward heaven as the new Promised Land; they trace the path that leads through the trials that await the disciples of Christ. (CCC # 1820)

The yearning is within us and the answer to that deepest yearning of the human heart is found without in that which is so much more than any one individual and that to which all creation is moving – the very Kingdom of God. Due to this the theological virtue of hope fulfills our deepest individual yearning yet does so in a way that connects us to one another and to all creation. A “hope” that would separate and divide is, in fact, a false hope.

True hope also respects freedom. It cannot but respect freedom in order to be true to itself. I am now a priest of seventeen years and I have served in a variety of settings and I must admit that I have never before been in a setting (college campus ministry for five years) where people and groups are so intent on forming other persons in their own image while at the same time there is so much talk of “respect for free thought” and “being yourself”.  Why is it that “being yourself” means you have to look and act like everyone else?  This is across the board: social groups, academic groups and settings, religious groups, opposed to religion groups, whatever. There is this overwhelming push it seems to form others in one’s own image and this can be subtle or just outright blatant and manipulative in nature. In this context, if a group does not seek to form others in its own image and has developed the maturity to respect freedom then it is written off as just naïve, out of touch at best or questionable and even suspect at worse.

But true hope respects freedom. It must. This is why any form of totalitarianism (and there are many) that would restrict freedom and conscience, sometimes under the seemingly most benign and even most “positive” of reasons, in fact, ends up suppressing hope. Yet even though hope can be wounded it can never fully be lost because the author of hope is God himself.

If hope can be suppressed (but never fully lost) then it can also be cultivated in one’s life. How might we cultivate the ground of our lives in such a way that hope might come to dwell within us? Our faith gives some strong advice: turn to God and develop a relationship with him in both prayer and sacrament, avoid sin and evil, if one has sinned ask for mercy and pardon (i.e. the sacrament of reconciliation), get out of yourself and strive to live in harmony with others and even go beyond just that to specifically doing good for others and serving others – especially the poor and even those who oppose you, live in a community which supports and strives for all of the above mentioned, i.e. the Catholic Church.

Our own actions and also the actions of others upon us (both positive and negative) can either cultivate our life for hope or turn us further away from the possibility of hope. In this regard our choices and the choices of others do have effects and do carry consequences.

Hope is truly beautiful and when it is authentically found in the life of a person it does speak to the souls and deep yearning of others. In the person of hope we know that there is just something there that we ourselves are searching for.

Hope does not disappoint.

Why the recent HHS mandate is important to Catholics and why it should matter to everyone

On January 20, 2012 the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reaffirmed a rule that under the new health care law, virtually all private health care plans must cover sterilization, abortifacients, and contraception.

The rule is set to take effect August 1, 2012. Non-profit religious employers that do not now provide such coverage, and are not exempt under the rule’s extremely narrow definition of religious employer, will be given one year to comply.  One commentator noted that even Jesus and his disciples would not fall under the rule’s narrow definition of what accounts for a “religious employer”.

This ruling will force Catholic hospitals, universities and charity organizations that have historically provided immeasurable service to our society (especially to the poorest and most vulnerable) to provide this coverage for its employees even as it contradicts firmly held beliefs about the dignity of life and morality that these institutions are founded upon.

Cardinal-designate Timothy Dolan of New York has noted that this mandate is unprecedented in its narrow definition of what accounts for a religious employer and that it has drawn a definitive line in the sand.  “In effect, the president is saying that we have a year to figure out how to violate our consciences.”  
 
This is why this mandate matters to Catholics.  
 
Why should the mandate matter to others?  People of goodwill may not agree with the Catholic Church’s teachings on when life begins or about the purpose of the sexual union of man and woman but the mandate to violate ones conscience should give everyone pause.  One of the core beliefs that our nation is founded upon is the free exercise of religion and the right of men and women to live as their conscience determines.  
 
In May, 2011 Francis Cardinal George, O.M.I. of Chicago published a book entitled, “God in Action: How Faith in God Can Address the Challenges of the World.”  I would like to share a few quotes from this book that in many ways are proving to be quite prophetic.  
 
Public life, from a secularist point of view, must be constructed on the assumption that God does not exist or, if he does, that his existence makes no difference.  Secularism’s espousal of public atheism in this country is based not on racial superiority, as was the case in Nazi Germany, or on supposedly scientific history of class warfare, as was the case with Leninist states, but on the myth of human progress carried exclusively by a scientific method limited to the study of material reality.  This project occupies the entire ground of public human action and public discourse in the pursuit of truth. 
 
Freedom of religion extends beyond freedom of personal conscience and beyond freedom to worship.  It includes freedom for religious institutions to have a public voice, to be public actors.
 
When secular life is constituted without respect for religious freedom, it becomes profane, and persecution of religion becomes inevitable.  There is no guarantee that even democratic institutions will prevent this outcome.  Independent courts, a free press, an elected legislature can all be manipulated, and have been in our own history, to subvert various freedoms and reflect the prejudices of controlling interest groups as well as those of ordinary citizens.  
 

A government that determines what is a religious ministry and what is not, what is the nature of an institution such as marriage, which predates both Church and state and is the creature of neither, when human life begins and when it can be taken without a penal trial has exceeded the boundaries of limited governance and is already on the road to totalitarianism.  While democratic in form, it has betrayed human freedom.   
Some have referred to the recent HHS mandate as the “Obama administration’s war on the Catholic Church”.  I do not believe I would go that far and I think it wise to avoid such inflammatory and specific language which can make it seem like this is just a Catholic issue when it, in fact, carries truly important ramifications for everyone in our society.  Yes, Catholics, all Christians and all religious persons need to be concerned about this mandate but so do all Americans.  It is a First Amendment issue.  I respect the good that the Obama administration has achieved in very turbulent times and I am sure, that there are ways that the Church and the administration can work together for the common good.  But I would also say that it is exactly in turbulent times that we need to hold to our core principles rather than abandon them.   

 
I do not see the administration as so much intentionally opposed to religion as just more secularist in outlook and, I would say, a specific understanding of secularism that just does not “get” religion and therefore, knowingly or unknowingly, seeking to bracket religion off and leave it out of the equation.  Elsewhere in his book, Cardinal George (building on the thought of Bl. John Paul II) proposes an understanding of secularism as “the ground between the sacred and the profane” (“profane” here being used not in a negative, pejorative context but as that distinct from the purely sacred).  Proper secularism does not necessarily have to be held in opposition to the sacred and it is an injustice to both when it is solely understood this way.  Secularism can actually be the ground where religious thought and non-religious thought encounter, dialogue and mutually enhance one another.    
 
I remember being struck by a news clip I saw of the White House Christmas celebration and President Obama remarking how the Christmas “story” has inspired people throughout the centuries.  Now, Mr. Obama is our president and I respect him for that and he is a politician who knows how to choose words that appeal to a vast variety of people while not offending but I would beg to differ here with the president.  It is not a “story” that is at the core of my life and the purpose of my life; it is a continuing encounter I have with the living God who refuses to be controlled or locked away.  A secularism that seeks to bracket off the sacred just does not get this and that is a sad thing and it does not bode well for the future.  
 
Due to the reasons shared above, the HHS mandate does matter to everyone and to who we are as a nation and to what we say our core principles are. 
 
I encourage everyone to truly reflect and weigh out the consequences of this mandate. 
 
I encourage people to work to overturn this mandate and to respect the right of conscience.  

Fourth Sunday in Ordinary Time (B): The authority of Christ

In the course of his ministry Jesus asks an important question, “Who do people say that I am?”  It is important both for the response that is given (ultimately by Peter) but also for Jesus himself asking the question.  Jesus does not ask, “What are people saying about my teachings?”  He does not ask, “How do you think people are responding to my message?”  He asks, “Who do people say that I am?”

Elsewhere in the gospel Jesus says, “I am the way, the truth and the life.”  Fr. Robert Barron in his Catholicism series makes an important observation.  Among all the founders of the world’s great religions Jesus’ claim is unique.  Buddha says, “I have found a way.”  The Prophet Muhammad says, “I have received a revelation.”  On Mount Sinai Moses receives the Commandments.  All the founders point to a greater truth beyond themselves.  Jesus alone points to his very self.  “I am the way, the truth and the life.”  This one claim sets Jesus apart from all the rest and it demands of us a radical decision.  Either Jesus is who he claims to be or he is not. 

In today’s gospel (Mk. 1:21-28) there are two groups that encounter and witness this unique authority of Christ.  The first are the people gathered in the synagogue, “The people were astonished at his teaching, for he taught them as one having authority and not as the scribes.”  The second “group” is the unclean spirit, “What have you to do us, Jesus of Nazareth?  Have you come to destroy us?  I know who you are – the Holy One of God!”  These immediate reactions – the astonishment of the people, the fear of the unclean spirit – testify to the unique authority of Christ. 

It is helpful to remember that the word “authority” has its roots in a Latin word meaning, “to make grow.”  From this we can realize that one of the marks of true authority is that it is not in competition with others.  True authority does not need to suppress the other for its own sake and purposes.  This type of non-competitive authority can only come from Christ who is not just one other being among other beings but rather being itself.  “I am…”, says Jesus. 

There is a misunderstanding quite common in our day that leads to viewing God as opposed to my freedom.  This misunderstanding is that God is seen as the biggest, most powerful, most omniscient being of all.  This is not the case.  Get rid of all those categories and thoughts!  God is not “a being” among other beings, God is being itself and therefore God is not opposed to my freedom but rather God is the very foundation and source of true freedom. 

This unique authority of Christ which is non-competitive, which does not need to suppress the other, which by its very nature and presence calls forth life (knowledge and deep insight for those people gathered in the synagogue, healing and freedom for the man imprisoned by the unclean spirit) witnesses to the unique reality of Christ – “I am the way, the truth and the life.” – and it demands of us a radical choice. 

Third Sunday in Ordinary Time (B): A very imperfect church, response to Jefferson Bethke and Spoken Word

I have been reading Fr. James Martin’s new book, “Between Heaven and Mirth.” In the book Fr. Martin reflects on the role of humor in the life of faith and throughout the reflection he scatters humorous jokes and stories. In chapter four he reflects on “serious reasons for good humor” – the last reason he lists is the practical nature of humor and he does this in a tongue-in-cheek way by sharing a story about his father’s cousin Bernie.

Bernie, it seems, lived in Philadelphia but owned a small store on the coast in New Jersey. One evening he was speeding down the interstate toward his store. He was late for an appointment. It was the last day of the month so he knew that the police officers would be out, eager to give tickets in order to make their quota. But, he was in a hurry and decided to take his chances doing about eighty miles an hour.

Sure enough, after crossing into New Jersey he saw the flashing red lights and was pulled over. The officer walked up to his car with a pleased look on his face. “I have been waiting for you all day!” said the officer.

Bernie, off the top of his head replied, “Well, I got here as fast as I could!” Fr. Martin concludes, “The officer laughed so hard that he didn’t give Bernie a ticket.”

It is good to laugh.

Mark’s gospel is the shortest and most succinct of the canonical gospels. One can feel throughout Mark’s account of the good news a sense of urgency. Jesus has a mission and time must not be wasted! This sense of urgency is given expression in the very first chapter. Jesus proclaims, “This is the time of fulfillment. The Kingdom of God is at hand.” (Mk. 1:15) But then what does he do? With this sense of urgency it would be expected that he would march straight to Jerusalem in order to set things right. But he does not do that. Rather, in this time of fulfillment, Jesus forms community (Church) and not only that but a community of very insignificant people who were certainly not on any “A-list” of their day – fishermen, tax collectors, religious zealots. They were people of no real consequence.

Also, they were a group of imperfect people. They disagreed, they argued with one another, they were fearful, they bore resentments, they miscommunicated, they did not always understand, one betrayed Jesus and another denied him. In other words, they were human, just like us. And Jesus was in their midst and Jesus is in our midst calling, healing and enabling us (in all of our imperfections) to be church for one another and for the world.

Recently there has been a Youtube video that has sparked discussion. In the video a young rapper who has all the right looks and wears the perfect cool style of clothing and has all the perfect video angle shots raps about how he loves Jesus but hates religion. He goes on to say that Jesus hates religion and therefore the church also. Isn’t it nice when Jesus agrees with our own point of view? He raps that religion told him to pretend to be perfect but he does not consider the possibility that maybe he was the one who was getting the message wrong from the beginning.

To this young man I would say re-read the gospels because I think you missed something. Consider today’s gospel (Mk. 1:14-20) where Jesus in the very urgency of proclaiming the Kingdom decides to gather a community of very imperfect believers and he decides to remain within their very midst. Consider where Jesus says that he is the vine and we are the branches. Consider the sending of the Holy Spirit upon the community gathered at Pentecost. Reflect on Paul’s beautiful analogy of Christ being the head of the body and we the members. Consider Paul’s own conversion on the road to Damascus when the exalted Lord instead of asking, “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute my followers?’ rather asks, “Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?” (Acts 9:4).  Consider the beautiful imagery of the bride awaiting the bridegroom found throughout the New Testament.

In the urgency of proclaiming the Kingdom, isn’t it interesting that Jesus calls and gathers a community of very imperfect people and he remains in their midst.

He remains in the midst of the Church today.

The Dangers of Radical Secularism

In a recent meeting with U.S. Bishops in Rome, Pope Benedict XVI made some pointed comments about the dangers of radical secularism in the United States.  It is a valid point that the anthropology of radical secularism is very limited and limiting.  It does not allow for the full dignity of the human person.  The best it can offer is an isolated individualism.   

Our Lady of Tenderness icon

I just completed the icon of Our Lady of Tenderness.

With us Mary stands in need of a saviour; yet who else cradled the infant saviour in her arms providing him warmth and nourishment, who else sang him to sleep, who else wiped away his tears and gave him encouragement?

When Jesus saw his mother and the disciple whom he loved standing beside her, he said to his mother, ‘Woman, here is your son.’ Then he said to the disciple, ‘Here is your mother.’ (John 19:26-27)

It is a tender thing our Lord does; as he is dying he finds a home for his mother and he gives his Church a mother.

Tenderness is not weakness.

Tenderness reveals the strength of love.

Mary, gentle woman and first of disciples pray with us and for us!

Second Sunday in Ordinary Time (B): National Vocation Awareness Week and Authentic Love

Fr. Robert Barron has remarked that authentic love can be defined as “seeking the good of the other for the sake of the other.”  This is a thoughtful definition of love and the second aspect is of utmost importance.  We are very good at caving in on ourselves in sin and this can even effect our love for another.  When I seek the good of the other because I get something out of it (my needs or insecurities are satisfied, my status, acceptance or even power is enhanced) then I am not authentically loving.  It is only when I can let go of myself and love the other person solely for the sake of the other person without heeding any benefit or counting any cost that it can be said that I am authentically loving.  Love, when it is real, is challenging and it calls for a letting go of self.

This past week has been National Vocation Awareness Week – an opportunity for the Church in the United States to reflect on vocation and pray for an increase in an overall awareness of the universal call to holiness and discipleship and specifically vocations of lives of service within the Church – found in priesthood, consecrated life and the permanent diaconate.  The readings for this Sunday with the call of the prophet Samuel (1 Samuel 3:3-10, 19) and the disciples (John 1:35-42) are very fitting for this.  The readings have much to teach us about God’s call and our responding and one aspect of this, I believe, is to help us recognize that call or vocation is rooted in authentic love.  At the beginning (even birthpoint, I would say) of both Samuel’s call and that of the disciples we find the witness of a love lived authentically.  This is not a coincidence I believe and is worthy of reflection.

Samuel was a young boy when God’s call came to him.  He was assisting the elderly priest Eli.  At first Samuel does not recognize the voice of God and neither does Eli, he thinks that the boy is dreaming things.  Samuel needs the direction and insight of his elder but he also needs his elder to show an authentic love for him.  After the third call, Eli recognizes what is going on – that God himself is calling the young boy.  It is here that Eli faces a critical moment – he can be resentful that God is calling this young boy and not himself (the “priest”), he can despair that this is an indicator that his time is over and now it is time for the younger generation, he can try to cling on and deny Samuel his moment.  He can do all of this by remaining silent to what he knows and telling Samuel to ignore the voice, that it is nothing.  But Eli does not do this and this is to his everlasting credit. “So (Eli) said to Samuel, ‘Go to sleep, and if you are called, reply, Speak, Lord, for your servant is listening.”

Eli seeks the good of Samuel for the sake of Samuel and not for his own sake.  Eli is able to show authentic love for Samuel.  He is able to let go of self for the good of the other.  And Samuel’s vocation is born.

John the Baptist also stands at a critical moment.  The gospels tell us that people from all over were coming to be baptized by John in the Jordan.  He had a devoted group of disciples, the religious authorities held a begrudging respect for John, even King Herod feared the prophet.  Many would say that John was at the “height of his power.”  John knows the yearning of the people and of his disciples for the Messiah.  Jesus walks by as John is standing there with two of his disciples.  He knows their yearning and he knows that he cannot answer that yearning.  It is beyond him.  He lets go of self and seeking the good of his two disciples for their good and not his own he points to Jesus and says, “Behold, the Lamb of God.”  They have found the Messiah and their calling is born.

We are Church.  We are meant to help one another along.  There is much concern today about the need for vocations to lives of service within the Church and for our world.  Today’s readings have much to teach us.  One of the lessons I believe is that the witness of authentic love is the necessary seedbed of vocations.  The witness of both Eli and John the Baptist testifies to this. 

Love calls forth love.

Our faith as Christians calls us to love authentically – seeking the good of the other for the sake of the other.     

Our Lady of Tenderness

I have gotten a little farther along on the icon of Our Lady of Tenderness. Yesterday’s quiet rainy afternoon helped. My third year of theology studies I really wrestled with the possibility of the monastic life. I don’t doubt my vocation as a diocesan priest but the idea of solitude in God remains very compelling for me. Of course the fact that the semester is beginning in just a couple of days now and things will once again be humming at the Catholic Center may also have something to do with these thoughts…

One of my resolutions for the new year is to get my spiritual house in order.  Recently I have had the spiritual intuition that God is asking something new of me.  I must admit that this thought had been weighing me down because I have been thinking solely in terms of something I need to give up or let go of but the other day the insight came to me as I was working on this icon that the “something new” God is asking of me is not another cross to carry but rather just to spend more time with Him in friendship and relationship. 

God wants time with me.  It is a very tender and life-giving invitation. 

I have made a reservation later this month for an overnight “quiet” day at Jubilee House (a retreat center) in Abingdon, VA.  My hope is to make this a monthly commitment.  Please help me by praying that I follow through and am able to keep this commitment. 

It is a beautiful thing when our Lord invites us to come away and spend time with Him. 

Feast of the Epiphany – the fourth gift of the Magi

Rise up in splendor, Jerusalem!  Your light has come, the glory of the Lord shines upon you.  (Isaiah 60:1)

We are the new Jerusalem yet what does it mean to “rise up in splendor”?  To help us answer this we have the witness of the Magi in today’s gospel (Mt. 2:1-12).  Three times in these twelve verses from Matthew’s gospel the Magi rise and follow. 

First, the Magi have arisen to follow the star.  The Magi are Gentiles, they are not Jews.  They do not have the guidance of the Law and the Prophets.  Their guidance is God at work in creation. “Where is the newborn King of the Jews?  We saw his star at its rising and have come to do him homage.”  They trusted in the voice of God as they best heard it.  Trusting, they rose up and followed and this guidance took them as far as it could. 

The Magi arrive in Jerusalem.  Here the people of the covenant, the people formed by the Law and the Prophets, direct them.  “In Bethlehem of Judea, for it has been written through the prophets: And you Bethlehem, land of Judah, are by no means least among the rulers of Judah; since from you shall come a ruler, who is to shepherd by people Israel.”  Yet again, the Magi rise up in order to follow.  God’s voice in creation is fulfilled in the Law and the Prophets.

They find the “child with Mary his mother” and they do him homage by offering gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh.  They encounter Christ – the Word of the Father and the Word made flesh – through whom all things have come into being (John 1:3) and the very source and fulfillment of the Law and Prophets.  All peoples (Jews and Gentiles) are united in the revelation of Christ.  Now after encountering Christ and being guided by the voice of God in creation and in the Law and Prophets, the Magi recognize the voice of God within their very selves, “And having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed for their country by another way.” 

Three times the Magi rise up responding in trust and in faith – to God’s voice proclaimed in creation, to the voice of God found in the Law and the Prophets and to the very encounter with God in Christ.  The Magi rise up in “splendor” – a splendor not of their own making or doing but of faith in God’s will and God’s providence. 

In contrast to the Magi we have King Herod.  Herod did not rise up.  Herod sends the Magi on to Bethlehem but he himself remains behind trapped in his fear, his love of power and in all the sad violence and division of our world. 

There is a fourth gift that the Magi bring on this Feast of the Epiphany.  To the Christ child the Magi bring the gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh.  To us, the Magi bring the gift of faith.  “Rise up in splendor!” they proclaim.  Even in the darkness of uncertain times and struggle or maybe of loss, grief and fear.  Even in the times of violence, division and lack of peace.  Rise up in splendor!  Walk in the ways of faith and in the light of God!  Ours is a different way, because even in the midst of darkness, “upon you the Lord shines, and over you appears his glory.” 

If we receive and live this fourth gift of the Magi, this most precious gift of faith, we become a light even unto the world, “Nations shall walk by your light, and kings by your shining radiance.”

Rise up in splendor!